See the “Good American Family” Cast Side-by-Side with the Real People They Play from Natalia Grace's Chilling Case ‘Good American Family’ stars Ellen Pompeo as Kristine Barnett — the ...

On Good American Family, McGraw is played by Rob Nagle, a veteran of series like Good Trouble (2023–2024) and NCIS: Los Angeles (2018, 2022).

Pompeo told Variety that she hopes Good American Family helps people "question why we believe what we believe." The series presents multiple perspectives because it is split into two parts.