CoinTrackers.com estimates a penny in average conditions to be worth $8,000, and one in mint state could be valued at $25,000. Auction record: $172,500 The 1864 Indian Head penny has an “L” on the ...
You might be surprised what collectors value and how much items can be ... but it stands out from the Lincoln cent that followed. —Brittany Sulc See all of the most valuable Indian Head pennies. The ...