PCGS Vs. NGC - Coin Talk
WEBAug 18, 2009 · None crossed over to PCGS as AU58: 1909 $2.5 NGC AU58 = PCGS AU55. 1909 $5 NGC AU58 = PCGS AU50. 1909-D $5 NGC AU58 = PCGS AU55. 1909-$20 NGC AU58 = PCGS AU55. 1909/8 $20 NGC AU58 = PCGS AU55. In looking at the coins now that I sort of know how to grade them, I think the PCGS grades are accurate.
ANACS vs PCGS/NGC - Coin Talk
WEBOct 8, 2015 · The exact same coin would sell for the most money in a PCGS holder, somewhat less in an NGC holder, and the least in an ANACS holder. But in my experience, the coins in these holders looks exactly the same. In fact, there are some NGC guidelines that are stricter than PCGS, and ANACS grades many more variety and problem coins.
bulk grading process and honesty in coin grading PCGS vs. NGC
WEBJan 24, 2011 · PCGS however appears to be #1 although there are ngc enthusiasts that would argue that. In my opinion the coin should be graded based on the coin, not what someone else previously thought. But we have all heard stories that people have resubmitted coins multiple times and finally received a bump up.
PCGS vs. NGC – Some personal observations - Coin Talk
WEBMar 7, 2019 · PCGS and NGC are the leading grading services. All the rest fall into lower categories. I could discuss why that is, but that’s not what I want to do here. I want to compare the two services. I have long contended that PCGS is slightly more conservative than NGC overall for U.S. coins. The trouble with that blanket statement is that it does ...
PCGS vs. NGC for grading ultra modern coins (1965 and beyond)
WEBSep 20, 2011 · And not just with modern coins but with all coins. Yes PCGS is more conservative when grading this series, but NGC is more conservative when grading that series. Yes you can find where a given coin in a PCGS slab sold for more than one in an NGC slab, but you can also find examples - and not …
ICG vs PCGS, NGC - Coin Talk
WEBJan 27, 2006 · Looking at auction records, I find that NGC coins tend to go for generally 10-40% less than PCGS or ANACS coins. ANACS and PCGS seem to be a much more realistic gradewise than NGC. Looking at, for example, Liberty Head nickels, I have seen NGC MS-67 and 68's commonly, and once in a while a 69.
Why PCGS is better than NGC - Coin Talk
WEBDec 15, 2019 · Unfortunately, I think both NGC/PCGS have let their grades creep upwards over time, e.g. gradeflation. I know myself and various others on the Coin Talk website were pissed off at NGC for a couple of years ago disallowing new PCGS slabbed coins to be included in their Registry sets. Before that my purchases were roughly 1/4 - 1/3 NGC slabs.
ICG vs PCGS, NGC | Page 2 | Coin Talk
WEBJan 27, 2006 · If you look at the population reports you will see that PCGS and NGC are more consistent with the amount of MS70 and PF70's. ICG and now more often ANACs give out a lot of MS70's and PF70's for certain coin's. The Kennedy's clad anniversary are a great example. How is it possible for ICG or ANACS have 100's of …
PCGS Vs. NGC in PF69 - Coin Talk
WEBAug 16, 2005 · Jefferson nickel - PCGS PF69 DCAM - 67,070. Jefferson nickel - NGC MS69 - 0 - - MS70 - 0. Jefferson nickel - PCGS MS69 - 1,077 - - MS70 - 79. These numbers are representative across the board for the various coin series. And they occur while NGC is grading more coins than PCGS does. It tells a bit of a different story.
PCGS Vs NGC, Which Is Worth More? - Coin Community Forum
WEBDec 19, 2018 · Usually PCGS is the preferred grading company but only slightly and only for coins with a value above $500 or so. For a cheaper coin (<$100) there is effectively no difference, it's likely you just happened to find a coin that was priced closer to the FMV, or the NGC coin had a bit more eye appeal. Edited by Adam_E 12/18/2018 7:08 pm.